-
Have you ever been snacking on our outrageously sharp 13-year aged White Cheddar and thought to yourself, "This is so good, I wish I had a tub of it to smear on everything in sight?” Us too! So we went ahead and created a spreadable version of our signature cheese that we know you’ll love! Our 1-pound tubs are a delightful dairy treat - we blended our 13-year Wicked White cheddar with some Grade A Wisconsin Cheddar to get the perfect balance of tangy, aged sharpness and creamy, spreadable goodness. And since our Aged White Cheddar spread is so popular, we've added Herb & Garlic and Port Wine Cheese Spread. Try all three! Like any fine aged cheddar, our spread is best if you give it a little time to breathe once you take it out of the refrigerator…if you can control yourself!
-
Get ready to meet your new snack obsession: The Big Cheese Spicy Beer Cheese Spread! Made with a 15-year-aged Wisconsin cheddar that’s as sharp as your wittiest friend, this spread is a perfect blend of creamy, spicy, and unapologetically cheesy goodness. It’s got just the right amount of heat to keep things interesting, plus a touch of craft beer because, well, it’s Wisconsin. Perfect for pairing with pretzels, crackers, or on your favorite burger, this spread is a must for game days, family gatherings, or a mid-afternoon snack.
-
Aged for a brief 11 years, this white cheddar is the new kid on the block... or is it off the block? It’s extra creamy and super smooth, but don’t worry, this cheddar still packs a sharp punch.
Pairs well with crusty breads, seasoned pretzels, multi-grain crackers, dried fruit and nuts, and mustard. Enjoy with a semi-sweet red wine, champagne, an amber lager or your favorite citrus-based IPA or pale ale!
15 oz. Wicked White Aged Cheddar -
For those who want to savor a devilishly smooth cheddar with a salty edge that will leave you wanting more, try our 13-year aged cheddar.
Pairs perfectly with dried oranges and other citrus, sweet onion sauces, steak, rye and pumpernickel breads. It’s delightful with your favorite rosé, chardonnay, or IPA.
-
Not all that glitters is gold. In this case, it’s the deliciously crunchy calcium crystals in our finely aged 13-year golden cheddar cheese. This incredible cheese has a slightly crumbly, perfectly creamy texture and a bold flavor that is nutty, tangy, and just a little bit feisty.
Pairs perfectly with dried sausage or liver pate, dried tomatoes, dried cranberries, wheat and sourdough breads. It's amazing with acidic white wines, pinot grigio, and red ales.
-
We like to have a good time and we know you do too. You want to try a little bit of everything because you’re curious with an adventurous side. Choose a trio of our 7 oz. blocks of white or golden 13-year cheddar, or one 15 oz. block each of our white and golden 13-year cheddars. Maybe age matters? Try a bit of each!
Remember, a party without cheese is just a meeting.
-
Our popcorn is drenched in real cheddar cheese and popped in pure coconut oil, with no trans fats or preservatives. The Big Cheese popcorn case comes with 12 individual 3-oz bags, for your own good, trust us. There is nothing skinny about this popcorn—there’s so much cheese your fingertips will be glistening by the time you’re done!
And we herd you! Back by popular demand, our Mexican Street Corn popcorn will have you saying mooo-ve over to boring snacks!
-
Out of stockOur The Big Cheese Small Gift Box is the perfect companion for any celebration! Our small gift box includes: 3oz Big Cheese Golden Cheddar Popcorn 3oz Big Cheese White Cheddar Popcorn 7oz 13-Year Aged White Cheddar 7oz 13-Year Aged Golden Cheddar 16oz Big Cheese Aged Cheese Spread 2.2oz Carr’s Table Water Crackers Bee’s Wrap Reusable Cheese Paper – Large Wrap (1)
-
Out of stockOur The Big Cheese Medium Gift Box is the perfect companion for any celebration! Try our delicious cheese in cheddar, spread, and popcorn form! It's a little bit of everything we have to offer - but don’t you worry, it’s most definitely big enough for a bold time. Our medium gift box includes: 3oz Big Cheese Golden Cheddar Popcorn 3oz Big Cheese White Cheddar Popcorn 15oz 11-Year Aged White Cheddar 15oz 13-Year Aged White Cheddar 16oz Big Cheese Aged Cheese Spread 2.2oz Carr’s Table Water Crackers Bee’s Wrap Reusable Cheese Paper – Large Wrap (1)
-
Our The Big Cheese Large Gift Box is the perfect gift for the host or delicious accompaniment for any party! Try our white and our golden at the same time – in cheddar, spread, and popcorn form! It's a little bit of everything we have to offer – but don’t you worry, it’s most definitely big enough for a bold time. Our large gift box includes: 3oz Big Cheese Golden Cheddar Popcorn 3oz Big Cheese White Cheddar Popcorn 15oz 13-Year Aged White Cheddar 15oz 13-Year Aged Golden Cheddar 16oz Big Cheese Aged Cheese Spread 16oz Big Cheese Port Wine Cheese Spread 16oz Big Cheese Herb & Garlic Cheese Spread 2.2oz Carr’s Table Water Crackers Bee’s Wrap Reusable Cheese Paper – Assorted 3-Pack