BOLD WISCONSIN CHEDDAR

The Big Cheese

Our Wisconsin cheddar was lovingly handcrafted and then aged to absolute perfection. It’s big. It’s bold. It’s sharp as sh*t. It’s the perfect cheese for any occasion – a milestone event, a romantic date night, or a Wednesday.

FAN FAVORITES

Popular Products

Handcrafted gourmet Wisconsin cheese aged to perfection & delivered with love straight to your door.
Click below to shop our Aged Wisconsin Cheddar, Popcorn, and More!

Gift Boxes
Aged Cheddar Cheeses
Popcorn
Cheese Spread

READ OUR MOOO-VING REVIEWS

OUR HERD HAS SPOKEN

We’re proud to be on your table, in your fridge, and a critical part of your mid-night snack. We udderly adore our Big Cheese herd!

(over 430 reviews!)

Biggest mistake of the order. I only ordered ONE!
~ Debra B.

Be like Gollum and hide it in the fridge in an incognito brussels sprouts container, while muttering madly “My Precious….”
~ Michael H.

Wow! Hands down the best cheese I’ve ever had. This stuff literally melts in your mouth. Its like candy, it’s so good.
~ David F.

The Big Cheese makes the best gifts. I always get rave reviews from the recipients, which is why I continue to gift this super cheesy gift every year.

~ Kelly

It is heaven on a hamburger.
~ John S.

This cheese is amazing!! best cheese we have ever had, hands down.
~ Chris Y.

Best cheese I ever tasted. Won’t buy anything else from now on.
~ Mic L.

Best cheese I ever tasted. Won’t buy anything else from now on.
~ Mic L.

Magnificent! Great with a Cabernet or Riesling. I made the most incredible pimiento cheese with this combined with the golden 13-year. Food for the Gods!
~ Thomas D.
The texture and sharpness was like nothing I have ever had before.
~ Mike B.
All the beautiful qualities that make a sharp cheddar are at their peak in The Big Cheese.
~ Amanda G.

Yum yum yum. The taste is so bold, so rich, so everything!
~ Kelley

You have a customer for life! Your cheese went beyond my expectations! Outstanding sharp cheddar
~ Kyle B.
Excellent aged cheddar cheese. I will purchase more in the future.
~ Gary S.
The complexity of this divine treat produces an explosion of flavors that your taste buds will remember and crave for in the future.
~ Jamie G

3rd Annual Cheese Eating Contest during Plymouth Cheese Festival in Plymouth, WI.